Daniel Kuehn writes,
What does the great jobs news say about QE3, given that a lot is revision of summer numbers? This is an economy healing itself. You can’t exactly credit fiscal policy, which has been the principle drag on growth lately. You can credit fiscal policy for avoiding a depression earlier on, I think.
My answer: I agree, neither fiscal policy nor QE3, but the market.
To clarify, Daniel is referring to the revision of employment figures. We all know I disagree with Daniel on fiscal policy in general, but it’s not an issue since he thinks that fiscal policy couldn’t have had an impact. Neither am I a fan of quantitative easing, but even if I were to concede that it could have a positive impact, QE3 is too recent to impact employment revisions. The third option is that the market is recovering on its own, and I think this is precisely what is happening.
(Of course, as one could probably guess, I’m of the opinion that it would have recovered much, much sooner had there been a “proper” period of liquidation.)
- Fiscal Policy and Taxation
In weighing whether Herbert Hoover's presidency was characterized by austerianism or fiscal expansionism, Daniel Kuehn points to the fact that Hoover raised taxes. Daniel concludes, in an absolute...
- Fiscal Monetary Policy
In a comparison between fiscal and monetary stimulus, Brad DeLong notes that in the event of a liquidity trap, monetary policy becomes difficult, because: (i) it either forces the Federal Reserve,...
- Pro-Market Fatal Conceit?
Bob Murphy commits to a second round with Nick Rowe on 'QE3,' and several people in the comments section take the subject in an interesting direction. Specifically, 'Blackadder' asks whether promot...
- Hidden Messages
Very briefly, Steve Horwitz offers undergrads an opportunity to be published on one of the Freeman's blogs by explaining why yesterday's Doonesbury is "fallacious" ("without defending Romney"). At...
Okay, so the title is a poor play on words (see below). Moving on.
Daniel Kuehn comments on Greg Mankiw's recent blog post, "The Liquidity Trap May Soon Be Over." I do not have much to say on ...