One Paragraph Summation: the Case for Immigration

The Machinery of Freedom (Friedman)As long as the immigrants pay for what they use, they do not make the rest of the society poorer. If increased population makes the country more crowded, it does so only because the immigrants produce wealth which is worth more to the owners of land than the land is worth, and the immigrants are able to use that wealth to buy the land. The same applies to whatever the immigrants get on the free market; in order to appropriate existing resources for their own uses, the immigrants must buy them with new goods of at least equal value.

— David Friedman, The Machinery of Freedom (New Rochelle: Arlington House, 1973), pp. 95–96.

It’s hard to put it any better. Many people, although probably less than in 1973, are concerned that a large immigrant population will require the pie to be cut into smaller pieces. The fact is, however, that in order to have a piece of the pie the migrant first has to produce a piece of his own that he can use to exchange. As such, if migrants are to find living in a foreign land successful they’ll have to add to national income, otherwise they can’t join in on the network of exchanges that makes up our economy.

Related Posts

  • Rent-Seeking and Ignorance
    A politician who can regulate an industry gets much more by helping the industry, whose members know and care about the effects of the regulation, than by helping the mass of consumers, who do not ...
  • The Other Other Side of Immigration
    Most of the time, the immigration policy debate is set up as being between nativists and advocates of unrestricted migration. I use the two extremes to characterize each side, but I mean to include...
  • Crisis Migration
    Alvaro Vargas Llosa, at the Beacon, blogs on falling immigration rates during crisis years and border enforcement.  His main point is to deny border enforcement policy any credit for this phenomeno...
  • Immigration Policy
    Daniel Kuehn, Noah Smith, and others, are discussing immigration policy.  I have not read all the relevant posts, but from what I understand Smith is looking for immigration reform in favor of high...
  • Misleading Titles
    The May 21 edition of the Christian Science Monitor arrived yesterday, and the cover story title runs, "When Prison Doors Swing Open: A Record Number of Inmates are Being Released From State Prison...